When looking to buy a used Toyota GR86, reliability is one of the most important things to consider. While the GR86 is known for its fun handling and sporty feel, not all model years are equally dependable. Some versions have had issues like GR86 engine reliability concerns, Toyota GR86 oil starvation issue, and minor GR86 mechanical issues, especially in early production years. On the other hand, certain years stand out for their solid performance and durability, making them great options for long-term ownership. In this guide, we’ll explore the most reliable years for Toyota GR86, helping you choose the best model year that delivers both excitement and peace of mind.
Why Reliability Matters in a Used Sports Car
When shopping for a used sports car, reliability is crucial. The Toyota GR86 is known for its performance, but understanding its dependability helps avoid unexpected repairs. A reliable car ensures more driving enjoyment and fewer trips to the mechanic.
The GR86 is popular among enthusiasts for its handling and affordability. However, some models have experienced issues like engine failures and oil starvation. Knowing which years are more dependable can save money and provide peace of mind.
Toyota GR86 vs Scion FR-S vs Toyota 86: A Quick Evolution Timeline
The Scion FR-S debuted in 2012, offering a lightweight, rear-wheel-drive experience. In 2017, it was rebranded as the Toyota 86, continuing the tradition with minor updates. The Toyota GR86 launched in 2022, featuring a more powerful engine and improved handling.
Each iteration built upon the previous model’s strengths. The GR86 introduced a 2.4-liter engine, addressing the power concerns of earlier versions. However, early GR86 models faced challenges like oil starvation, which were less prevalent in the FR-S and 86.
Best Toyota GR86 and 86 Model Years by Reliability Score
Reliability scores vary across model years. According to owner reviews and expert analyses, the 2023 GR86 stands out for its improved dependability. Earlier models like the 2015 Scion FR-S also received high marks for reliability.
Here’s a table summarizing reliability scores:
| Model Year | Reliability Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| 2015 FR-S | 86/100 | High reliability, affordable |
| 2016 FR-S | 83/100 | Slightly lower score, still dependable |
| 2017 86 | 82/100 | Good balance of performance and reliability |
| 2022 GR86 | 77/100 | Early engine issues reported |
| 2023 GR86 | 78/100 | Improved reliability over 2022 model |
2022 Toyota GR86: A New Chapter with Some Growing Pains
The 2022 GR86 introduced a 2.4-liter engine, enhancing performance. However, some owners reported engine failures due to oil starvation, especially during aggressive driving or track use. These issues were linked to the FA24 engine shared with the Subaru BRZ.
Toyota addressed these concerns by investigating affected vehicles and, in some cases, replacing engines under warranty. Despite these efforts, the early reliability issues impacted consumer confidence in the 2022 model.
2023–2024 Toyota GR86: More Reliable, More Refined
The 2023 GR86 saw improvements in build quality and a reduction in reported engine issues. Toyota’s adjustments to manufacturing processes and quality control contributed to these enhancements. The introduction of special trims like the Trueno Edition added appeal.
Early reports on the 2024 GR86 are promising, with no widespread reliability concerns. However, as it’s a newer model, long-term dependability data is still emerging. The 2023 GR86 currently represents a balanced choice between performance and reliability.
Hidden Gems: Best Pre-2020 FR-S & 86 Models to Buy Used
For budget-conscious buyers, earlier models like the 2015 Scion FR-S and 2016 FR-S offer reliable performance at lower prices. These models have fewer reported issues and provide a pure driving experience.
The 2017 Toyota 86 introduced minor updates and maintained a good reliability record. These pre-2020 models are considered hidden gems for those seeking affordable, dependable sports cars.
Key Reliability Factors to Consider Before Buying Used
When purchasing a used GR86, FR-S, or 86, consider the following:Hagerty
-
Maintenance history: Regular servicing indicates proper care.
-
Mileage: Lower mileage often means less wear and tear.
-
Track use: Cars used on tracks may have experienced more stress.
-
Recalls and repairs: Check if necessary fixes have been completed.
A thorough inspection by a qualified mechanic can uncover potential issues before purchase.
Used Toyota GR86 Pricing Guide (Fair Market Value by Year)
Understanding market prices helps in making informed decisions. Here’s a table with average prices:
| Model Year | Average Price (USD) |
|---|---|
| 2015 FR-S | $12,000 |
| 2016 FR-S | $13,500 |
| 2017 86 | $15,000 |
| 2022 GR86 | $27,000 |
| 2023 GR86 | $28,500 |
Prices vary based on condition, mileage, and location. Always compare listings and consider certified pre-owned options for added assurance.
Final Verdict: The Most Reliable Toyota GR86 Years
Considering performance and reliability, the 2023 GR86 stands out as the most dependable choice. It benefits from Toyota’s refinements and has fewer reported issues compared to the 2022 model.
For those on a tighter budget, the 2015 Scion FR-S and 2016 FR-S offer reliable alternatives. These models have proven track records and provide an engaging driving experience.
FAQs About Buying a Used Toyota GR86 or FR-S
What is the lifespan of the GR86?
The Toyota GR86 can last 200,000 miles or more with proper maintenance and careful driving.
Is Toyota GR86 expensive to maintain?
No, the Toyota GR86 is relatively affordable to maintain, with average yearly costs lower than many other sports cars.
What is the most reliable 86?
The 2023 Toyota GR86 is considered the most reliable 86 so far, thanks to key engine refinements and fewer reported issues.
What is the best GT86 model?
The 2017 Toyota 86 is often rated the best GT86 model for its improved handling, refreshed styling, and solid reliability.
What years to avoid for a Toyota 86?
Avoid the 2013 and 2022 models, as they have higher reports of engine issues and reliability concerns.
Read our previous article: Black Hole Dance Illuminates Hidden Math of the Universe